Cherry and Hattie, two Mainland students, BBQing it upOne of our main duties as ETAs is to go on weekend field trips with the students. Ever since we have started work, we have not had one weekend free:( Kinda sad but it has been fun getting to interact with my students outside of the classroom. It becomes clear the social and cultural dynamics between the students when they are socializing outside of class. Students from the mainland only interact with each other, as do the students from Macau are isolated to themselves. The class is a microcosm of the greater Macau society. At my BBQ, today the students were clearly divided to two distinct groups - one Macau group speaking Cantonese and one Mainland group speaking Mandarin. Nobody really talked about the division but it was definitely there and you could almost feel it.
As I spend more time here, I feel that the division between the two Chinese groups is a very clear and distinct divide that is hardly crossed. Those from HK and Macau often speak Mandarin and Cantonese but make a definite effort not to speak Mandarin to interact with the Mainland students. I find it disheartening to know that the students choose not to speak and socialize with the Mainlanders, even though they can. They speak Cantonese as a method to exclude those students from mainland. Making it clear to them, they are not from the mainland.
From those I've spoken to from HK and Macau, there are strong feelings of superiority to those from the mainland. I'm not sure where this superiority feeling comes from. I'm assuming that their colonization period makes them different from those from mainland. In addition, HK and Macau's economy has been well established prior to the sudden surge in economic growth in Mainland. In addition, the communism in China is another point in which the HK people discourage; often saying that the mainland's government is 'corrupt' and 'evil', and the source of shady business. HK's resistance to celebrating People's Republic of China Day just shows how they do not want to glorify the communist government. The poor dress and rude mannerisms of the mainlanders is often noted. After the turnover back to China, HK and Macau had a flood of mainlanders looking for work, but they were definitely not welcomed with open arms. Though HK and Macau has returned back to China, there is lack of national unity among the people - we are all Chinese but we are not all the same.
Speaking to my mainland students, they too feel that they are a bit discriminated against here in Macau and Hong Kong. They are well aware of the social biases of the HK and Macau people. Their use of Mandarin as their distinguishing feature of being mainland. The divide between the Macau people and mainlanders is a bit better here because of the large influx of mainland gamblers, but still there are negative preconceptions of mainlanders. These disapproving feelings may be why the Mainland China people always stick together. I wonder with time, will there be greater integration among the two groups? What must be changed in order for that to take place? A change of attitude, preconceptions, beliefs, etc...



























